View All Photos
$725,000
Active37 W Fall Creek Parkway South Drive
Indianapolis, IN 46208

Rare investment opportunity in the Near Northside/Fall Creek Place corridor: a 1913 Craftsman fourplex with four legal units and 10 bedrooms across approximately 6,400 SF, already operating as a hybrid short-term rental and long-term primary residence with a potential cap rate approaching 9-10%. The main floor and full basement (7 bedrooms) run as an established, Superhost-rated Airbnb with a proven booking history - seller is offering a 3-6 month co-hosting transition so a buyer inherits the reviews and ranking rather than starting from zero. The upper floor is a spacious 3BD/2BA suite currently owner occupied. Original inlaid hardwood floors, tiled fireplaces, and custom millwork throughout, plus an original tile roof with a matching surplus of spare tiles included. Recent updates: full exterior repaint, all ~75 original windows and storm windows repaired, 2024 condenser replacement, HVAC service plans maintained on both systems, newer water heater/softener. Electric separately metered per unit. Off-street parking on two street frontages plus a one-car garage. Sold furnished, with the active short-term rental operation available to convey for a true turnkey opportunity. Buyer may also have the option to assume the seller's existing financing balance of 375k at 3% - a rate well below today's market - ask listing agent for details. Occupied; please do not disturb. Showings by appointment only.
Property Details
- Acres
- 0.18
- Parking Features
- Alley Access, Attached, Concrete
- Parking Spaces
- 1.0
- Parking Type
- Garage
- Parking Garage Spaces
- 1.0
- Basement
- 1
- Basement Description
- Apartment, Daylight, Egress Window(s), Exterior Entry, Finished, Finished Walls, Interior Entry, Walk-Out Access
- Basement Finished
- 1
- Year Built
- 1913
- Foundation
- Block, See Remarks
- Subdivision
- Rubens Wildwood
- School District
- Indianapolis Public Schools
- County
- Marion
- Region
- Indianapolis
- Original List Price
- $725,000
- Days on Market (Cumulative)
- 51
- MLS #
- 22124579
- Property Subtype
- Quadruplex
- Waterfront
- 1
- Parcel Number
- 490625134016000101
- MLS #
- 22124579
- Waterfront Type
- Water View
- Waterfront Features
- Water View
- Date Listed
- September 18, 2026
- Address
- 37 W Fall Creek Parkway South Drive
Location
Legal
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Last Updated: Nov 8, 2026 1:06 AM. Source: MIBOR
Listing Broker: Liz Foley Real Estate, Inc.; Alexander Foley; xanderfoley27@gmail.com

Interested in Purchasing 37 W Fall Creek Parkway South Drive?
Get an estimate on monthly payments on this property.