Back

About New Castle, IN

City Guide

About New Castle

Real Estate & Housing

Neighborhoods

Lifestyle in New Castle

Schools & Education

Getting Around

Parks & Recreation

MARKET SNAPSHOT

The Market at a Glance

How homes have been selling here over the last 90 days.

home_work New This Week 2
Went Under Contract 0
trending_down Price Reductions 0
payments Median Sale Price $169,900 +3.0%
square_foot Price per Sq Ft $97
schedule Avg Days on Market 19
sell Homes Sold 51
percent Sale-to-List Ratio 96.0%
inventory_2 Months of Inventory 7.8

Price & Sales History

Market data reflects closed sales over the last 90 days and is provided for informational purposes.

For sale

Houses in New Castle, IN

Handpicked properties hitting the scene in your area.

11217 Candice Drive For Sale
$339,000
11217 Candice DriveFishers, IN 46038
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2446 sqft
  • Built 2006
  • 22112224
F.C. Tucker Company
4164 Nigella Drive For Sale
$399,900
4164 Nigella DrivePlainfield, IN 46168
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2891 sqft
  • Built 2019
  • MBR22121953
CrestPoint Real Estate
112 W Ohio For Sale
$299,750
112 W OhioFortville, IN 46040
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1812 sqft
  • Built 1920
  • MBR22119909
Carpenter, REALTORS®
5880 Mason Court For Sale
$259,900
5880 Mason CourtMartinsville, IN 46151
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1120 sqft
  • Built 1967
  • 22105331
Crossroads Real Estate Group LLC
909 Farmview Lane For Sale
$439,900
909 Farmview LaneCarmel, IN 46032
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2040 sqft
  • Built 1986
  • MBR22117047
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
3675 W 558 For Sale
$319,900
3675 W 558Huntington, IN 46750
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2159 sqft
  • Built 1966
  • MBR22112905
NextHome Elite Real Estate
458 Chester Lane For Sale
$399,999
458 Chester LanePittsboro, IN 46167
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2446 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • MBR22121960
Pyatt Builders, LLC
347 Lake Ridge Lane For Sale
$249,000
347 Lake Ridge LaneGreenwood, IN 46142
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1234 sqft
  • Built 1994
  • 22104605
CENTURY 21 Scheetz
871 Maidstone Avenue For Sale
$310,000
871 Maidstone AvenueWestfield, IN 46074
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1359 sqft
  • Built 2014
  • MBR22121383
F.C. Tucker Company
2019 Haven Trail For Sale
$655,000
2019 Haven TrailMartinsville, IN 46151
  • 4 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 3626 sqft
  • Built 2006
  • MBR22118520
Carpenter, REALTORS®
For Sale
$350,000
18 Fairfield DriveBrownsburg, IN 46112
  • 4 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1790 sqft
  • Built 1962
  • MBR22121956
Integrity Real Estate
2132 Pennsylvania Street For Sale
$459,900
2132 Pennsylvania StreetIndianapolis, IN 46202
  • 3 bd
  • 3.5 ba
  • 2592 sqft
  • Built 2007
  • 22103392
United Real Estate Indpls

For sale

Townhomes in New Castle, IN

Handpicked properties hitting the scene in your area.

716 Garrow Drive For Sale
$328,000
716 Garrow DriveWestfield, IN 46074
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1854 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • MBR22121968
Pulte Realty of Indiana, LLC
3015 S Holt #C For Rent
$900
3015 S Holt #CIndianapolis, IN 46221
  • 1 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 6156 sqft
  • Built 1950
  • MBR22120548
Plum Tree Realty
1098 Cavendish Drive For Sale
$449,900
1098 Cavendish DriveCarmel, IN 46032
  • 3 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2232 sqft
  • Built 2004
  • MBR22119064
Real Broker, LLC
5992 Lomita Avenue For Sale
$310,000
5992 Lomita AvenuePlainfield, IN 46168
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1886 sqft
  • Built 2024
  • MBR22120638
eXp Realty LLC
3015 S Holt #B For Rent
$900
3015 S Holt #BIndianapolis, IN 46221
  • 1 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 6156 sqft
  • Built 1950
  • MBR22120547
Plum Tree Realty
3015 S Holt #A For Rent
$900
3015 S Holt #AIndianapolis, IN 46221
  • 1 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 6156 sqft
  • Built 1950
  • MBR22120468
Plum Tree Realty
728 Garrow Drive For Sale
$326,000
728 Garrow DriveWestfield, IN 46074
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1854 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • MBR22121746
Pulte Realty of Indiana, LLC
423 Leota Street For Sale
$385,000
423 Leota StreetIndianapolis, IN 46203
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1535 sqft
  • Built 2022
  • MBR22121356
Highgarden Real Estate
13484 Erlen Drive For Sale
$399,900
13484 Erlen DriveFishers, IN 46037
  • 3 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2359 sqft
  • Built 2020
  • 22099746
Carpenter, REALTORS®
1481 Whistle Way For Sale
$467,000
1481 Whistle WayWestfield, IN 46074
  • 3 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 2104 sqft
  • Built 2025
  • 22080077
Berkshire Hathaway Home
434 Monarch Lane For Sale
$299,695
434 Monarch LaneLebanon, IN 46052
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1706 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • MBR22121122
Compass Indiana, LLC
9032 Rider Drive For Sale
$355,000
9032 Rider DriveFishers, IN 46038
  • 3 bd
  • 3.5 ba
  • 2550 sqft
  • Built 2007
  • MBR22121077
New Quantum Realty Group

For sale

Condos in New Castle, IN

Handpicked properties hitting the scene in your area.

1926 Saint James Place For Sale
$235,000
1926 Saint James PlaceAnderson, IN 46012
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1580 sqft
  • Built 1986
  • MBR22121199
Carpenter, REALTORS®
For Sale
$289,000
11910 Riley Drive #4Zionsville, IN 46077
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1900 sqft
  • Built 2009
  • MBR22121951
MYL Realty, LLC
1131 Brunes Boulevard For Sale
$369,900
1131 Brunes BoulevardBrownsburg, IN 46112
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1690 sqft
  • Built 2004
  • MBR22120254
F.C. Tucker Company
3177 Sycamore Drive #5A For Sale
$199,900
3177 Sycamore Drive #5AColumbus, IN 47203
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1967 sqft
  • Built 1980
  • MBR22121808
1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate
20971 Shoreline Court #214 For Sale
$309,900
20971 Shoreline Court #214Noblesville, IN 46062
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1038 sqft
  • Built 2006
  • 22081237
Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners
450 E Ohio Street #202 For Sale
$365,000
450 E Ohio Street #202Indianapolis, IN 46204
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1522 sqft
  • Built 2004
  • MBR22121833
Daniels Real Estate
404 E New York Street #304 For Sale
$314,000
404 E New York Street #304Indianapolis, IN 46202
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1250 sqft
  • Built 1930
  • 22110052
eXp Realty, LLC
630 College Avenue #311 For Sale
$750,000
630 College Avenue #311Indianapolis, IN 46204
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2163 sqft
  • Built 1922
  • MBR22099307
F.C. Tucker Company
13535 Molique Boulevard For Rent
$2,195
13535 Molique BoulevardFishers, IN 46037
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2465 sqft
  • Built 2005
  • MBR22116375
Polaris Real Estate Group, INC
2248 Brightwell Place For Sale
$235,000
2248 Brightwell PlaceIndianapolis, IN 46260
  • 2 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 1581 sqft
  • Built 2005
  • MBR22121708
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
3419 Pennsylvania Street #C6 For Sale
$154,900
3419 Pennsylvania Street #C6Indianapolis, IN 46205
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1090 sqft
  • Built 1925
  • MBR22121684
GB Landrigan & Company
4235 Larkspur Trace For Sale
$145,000
4235 Larkspur TraceIndianapolis, IN 46237
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1337 sqft
  • Built 1974
  • MBR22121212
CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Get Alerts Advanced Search
  • Map
  • List
1930-1932 Fairmont Avenue For Sale
$189,900
1930-1932 Fairmont AvenueNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2563 sqft
  • Built 1940
  • MBR22121388
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
416 County Road 25 West For Sale
$299,900
416 County Road 25 WestNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2098 sqft
  • Built 1991
  • MBR22121409
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1316 R AVENUE For Sale
$124,900
1316 R AVENUENew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1592 sqft
  • Built 1938
  • MBR22119012
Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners
644 S 11th Street For Sale
$170,000
644 S 11th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2394 sqft
  • Built 1950
  • MBR22119358
F.C. Tucker Company
5358 E Woodruff Drive For Sale
$210,000
5358 E Woodruff DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1424 sqft
  • Built 1960
  • MBR22118411
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1127 Hickory Lane For Sale
$250,000
1127 Hickory LaneNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2006 sqft
  • Built 1977
  • MBR22081333
RE/MAX First Integrity
715 S 21st Street For Sale
$75,000
715 S 21st StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 2225 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • MBR22118235
Coldwell Banker Lingle
5158 NW High Street For Sale
$349,900
5158 NW High StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1409 sqft
  • Built 2026
  • MBR22118118
RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions
512 E County Road 300 S For Sale
$158,000
512 E County Road 300 SNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1075 sqft
  • Built 1972
  • MBR22117586
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1108 Audubon Road For Sale
$495,000
1108 Audubon RoadNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 3.5 ba
  • 4053 sqft
  • Built 1940
  • MBR22115649
Real Broker, LLC
1334 S Onyx Court For Sale
$349,000
1334 S Onyx CourtNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2192 sqft
  • Built 1982
  • MBR22091633
Berkshire Hathaway Home
1316 S 19th Street For Sale
$120,000
1316 S 19th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1056 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • MBR22116842
JMG Indiana
5230 W State Road 38 For Sale
$95,000
5230 W State Road 38New Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1118 sqft
  • Built 1870
  • MBR22116988
eXp Realty, LLC
2517 S 23rd Street For Sale
$147,500
2517 S 23rd StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 864 sqft
  • Built 1957
  • MBR22052083
Trusted Realty Partners of Ind
803 Vine Street For Sale
$109,000
803 Vine StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1825 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • MBR22116514
PMI Indianapolis
2616 Maple Drive For Sale
$210,900
2616 Maple DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1592 sqft
  • Built 1969
  • MBR22116418
F.C. Tucker Company
3019 Brentwood Road For Sale
$162,900
3019 Brentwood RoadNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1008 sqft
  • Built 1958
  • MBR22115496
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
241 Pleasantview Drive For Sale
$255,000
241 Pleasantview DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 4023 sqft
  • Built 1960
  • MBR22115245
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
2205 Plum For Sale
$84,900
2205 PlumNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1120 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22114139
Legacy Real Estate Partners
1328 S 20th Street For Sale
$128,400
1328 S 20th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 936 sqft
  • Built 1935
  • 22113489
Real Broker, LLC
129 Wildwood Boulevard For Sale
$194,500
129 Wildwood BoulevardNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1248 sqft
  • Built 1985
  • 22113273
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
2214 S 19th Street For Sale
$124,900
2214 S 19th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 816 sqft
  • Built 1925
  • 22102914
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
106 7th Street For Sale
$169,900
106 7th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1706 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22113139
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
143 S 9th Street For Sale
$109,900
143 S 9th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2320 sqft
  • Built 1953
  • 22112564
Taflinger Real Estate Group
2644 S Spiceland For Sale
$746,000
2644 S SpicelandNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 4 ba
  • 4734 sqft
  • Built 2004
  • 22111095
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
1208 Woodlawn Drive For Sale
$240,000
1208 Woodlawn DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 3292 sqft
  • Built 1916
  • 22110983
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
2514 S 23rd Street For Sale
$192,500
2514 S 23rd StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1164 sqft
  • Built 1952
  • 22111072
NextHome Elite Real Estate
1535 Swarthmoor Drive For Sale
$169,900
1535 Swarthmoor DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1104 sqft
  • Built 1954
  • 22110945
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
420 Phelps Drive For Sale
$259,900
420 Phelps DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1518 sqft
  • Built 1976
  • 22109247
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
2703 Spring Street For Sale
$119,900
2703 Spring StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1034 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22108742
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
2916 Country Estates Drive For Sale
$239,900
2916 Country Estates DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 1796 sqft
  • Built 1975
  • 22108292
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1857 County Road 300 Road W For Sale
$220,000
1857 County Road 300 Road WNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1744 sqft
  • Built 1948
  • 22107177
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1814 W Railroad Street For Sale
$199,900
1814 W Railroad StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 1 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1120 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22107048
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1619 P AVENUE For Sale
$97,000
1619 P AVENUENew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2499 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22093809
F.C. Tucker Company
1605 Cedar Drive For Sale
$215,000
1605 Cedar DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 2359 sqft
  • Built 1980
  • 22106474
REMAX ONE
1018 S 15th Street For Sale
$45,900
1018 S 15th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 808 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22107149
Legacy Real Estate Partners
938 County Road 275 E For Sale
$950,000
938 County Road 275 ENew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 2.5 ba
  • 5007 sqft
  • Built 2007
  • 22105841
Whitetail Properties
3640 Red River Road For Sale
$221,000
3640 Red River RoadNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1338 sqft
  • Built 1963
  • 22104292
Opendoor Brokerage LLC
1549 Thornburg Street For Sale
$144,900
1549 Thornburg StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2595 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22103034
Rhodes Realty, LLC
1121 Woodlawn Drive For Sale
$249,900
1121 Woodlawn DriveNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 3 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2984 sqft
  • Built 1940
  • 22102007
Epique Inc
722 24th Street For Sale
$54,900
722 24th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 720 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22101462
Legacy Real Estate Partners
1621 R AVENUE For Sale
$64,999
1621 R AVENUENew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1298 sqft
  • Built 1945
  • 22101229
FC Tucker Richmond
1718 Irvin Street For Sale
$70,000
1718 Irvin StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 1440 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22101038
Hemrick Property Group Inc.
921 14th Street For Sale
$227,900
921 14th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2768 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22098085
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads
1324 Thornburg Street For Sale
$89,000
1324 Thornburg StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2800 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22100062
FC Tucker Richmond
1324 J AVENUE For Sale
$82,499
1324 J AVENUENew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2640 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22099762
FC Tucker Richmond
422 S 18th Street For Sale
$65,000
422 S 18th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 5 bd
  • 2 ba
  • 2300 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22099719
FC Tucker Richmond
2301 S 19th Street For Sale
$94,900
2301 S 19th StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 660 sqft
  • Built 1955
  • 22097518
eXp Realty LLC
2645 S Greensboro Pike For Sale
$249,900
2645 S Greensboro PikeNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 4 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 2660 sqft
  • Built 1900
  • 22093672
RE/MAX First Integrity
1122 S 21st Street For Sale
$119,900
1122 S 21st StreetNew Castle, IN 47362
  • 2 bd
  • 1 ba
  • 2016 sqft
  • Built 1918
  • 22094943
F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

Nearby Cities

All Cities

Similar Searches

Featured Areas

All Areas

Featured Searches

Advanced Search

Popular Cities

All Cities

Popular Subdivisions

All Subdivisions

Popular Zip Codes

All Zips
Contact us

Hilary Casstevens

(317) 513-8929

hc@hilarycasstevens.com

Hilary Casstevens

501 Pennsylvania Parkway Suite 195 Indianapolis, IN 46280

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.